Topic: Flag Stolen
Egloshal
avatar
Posts: 576

Posted:
23.Apr 2008 - 15:55

THEFT OF FLAG BUDE

Police in North Cornwall are seeking witnesses following the theft of a flag from Bude Meteorological Station in Ergue Gaberaic Way in the town between 9.00 and 10.00 a.m. on Wednesday 23 April 2008.

The English flag, The Cross of St George, was flown to mark St Georges Day but stolen within the hour. It is values at around £20.

The suspect who removed the flag was wearing a red waterproof jacket with blue collar and cuffs.

Anyone who has any information regarding the theft is asked to call Crimestoppers on 0800 555111 quoting crime reference BU/08/273.

ENDS
230408

Police ref. BU/08/273



Radyo an Gernewegva
P_Trembath
online
avatar
Posts: 1080

Posted:
23.Apr 2008 - 16:11

I was wondering why I had not seen any so far today! icon_lol



Kernow Kensa!


Our day will come!


"Everyone has their own particular part to play. No part is too great or too small, no one is too old or too young to do something."
TheElvenLord
avatar
Posts: 969

Posted:
23.Apr 2008 - 16:13

Hmmm - Was there any Blood crosses in France? Spain? Germany? China? USA? NO

THERE SHOULDNT BE IN KERNOW EITHER

TEL

Everything is impossible until it is not.
shrdlu
avatar
Posts: 241

Posted:
23.Apr 2008 - 16:24

Theres a nice new one outside the Duke of Leeds today to replace the shredded rag thats hung there for months but I dont advocate nicking it
TheElvenLord
avatar
Posts: 969

Posted:
23.Apr 2008 - 16:35

The Royal Standard used to be 2 cornish flags, and now its 1 english 1 Cornish

The Duke of Leeds in Leedstown?

TEL

Everything is impossible until it is not.
marhak
avatar
Posts: 4470

Posted:
23.Apr 2008 - 21:02

Pity the Bude police don't have anything better to do. Like combatting crime, such as that committed when the English flag was raised there in the first place. (I'm sure there's a constitutional offence there but, failing that, there's incitement to racial hatred and conduct intended to cause a breach of the peace, at the very least).
Kéighlán
avatar
Posts: 440

Posted:
23.Apr 2008 - 22:10

I had Eggs thrown at my flag today. Not happy!!!

walk with Jesus! just look out for speedboats.
Kéighlán
avatar
Posts: 440

Posted:
23.Apr 2008 - 22:11

and 20 quid for a St Georges flag?
mine is pretty big and cost five pound


walk with Jesus! just look out for speedboats.
sharon
avatar
Posts: 408

Posted:
23.Apr 2008 - 23:07

KéighlánI had Eggs thrown at my flag today. Not happy!!!


How come?
sharon
avatar
Posts: 408

Posted:
23.Apr 2008 - 23:12

EgloshalTHEFT OF FLAG BUDE

Police in North Cornwall are seeking witnesses following the theft of a flag from Bude Meteorological Station in Ergue Gaberaic Way in the town between 9.00 and 10.00 a.m. on Wednesday 23 April 2008.

The English flag, The Cross of St George, was flown to mark St Georges Day but stolen within the hour. It is values at around £20.

The suspect who removed the flag was wearing a red waterproof jacket with blue collar and cuffs.

Anyone who has any information regarding the theft is asked to call Crimestoppers on 0800 555111 quoting crime reference BU/08/273.

ENDS


230408

Police ref. BU/08/273



It is totally pathetic that this is seen as a worthy news item, why are they making such a big deal out of it I wonder not.

I didn't see many G flags today 1 on the church at Breage and one in Mullion village.

CJenkin

Posts: 831

Posted:
24.Apr 2008 - 11:47

I didn't see any evidence of St. George in Cornwall yesterday but this is what the scots are saying
http://www.bbc....ges_day.html
goky
avatar
Posts: 1828

Posted:
24.Apr 2008 - 14:43

I thought the English flag was illegal even in England these days.

The blog The Great Goky Blog
Kéighlán
avatar
Posts: 440

Posted:
24.Apr 2008 - 16:25

1
yes it is illegal in some parts. i just didn't care it was St Georges day.
2
I had eggs thrown at my flag most probably because it's an English flag.

walk with Jesus! just look out for speedboats.
Mike
avatar
Posts: 2744

Posted:
24.Apr 2008 - 16:42

Kéighlán1
yes it is illegal in some parts. i just didn't care it was St Georges day.
2
I had eggs thrown at my flag most probably because it's an English flag.


Where is it illegal to fly the CStG flag in England?

Who would throw eggs at your flag in England?
TheElvenLord
avatar
Posts: 969

Posted:
24.Apr 2008 - 17:52

Mike

Everywhere but Cornwall

The Cornish

TEL


Everything is impossible until it is not.
marhak
avatar
Posts: 4470

Posted:
24.Apr 2008 - 19:44

I would assume that the flag was removed in order to avoid a breach of the peace, and to remove an incitement to racial hatred. Should anyone get their collar felt for this, I suggest that this be his/her defence.



edited by: marhak, Apr 24, 2008 - 06:44 PM
pfishwick
avatar
Posts: 277

Posted:
24.Apr 2008 - 22:24

Unsure why the removal of a £20 (that much? - decent ones, and for that matter CoSPiran flags as well, can be bought for much less) flag should be newsworthy when expensive weather equipment is stolen or damaged all too frequently at meteorological stations up and down Britain and Ireland, but the media remain silent. Some of this includes folk literally opening fire on the instruments. icon_eek

This incurs costly replacement charges and a loss of observations until new sensors are installed.

Maybe the BBC should report what's important and not what isn't (e.g. petty theft of a flag).

Nos da,

Patrick



"You can't have an isolated little UK on its own"

(Many thanks JA, just modified you words for the benefit of UKIP),

Europe for ever
Kéighlán
avatar
Posts: 440

Posted:
24.Apr 2008 - 22:46

Where is it banned and why mike?
i don't really know, but iv'e heard various storys on the bbc and from people who have been told to remove their flags, and it has been banned in some places (Bradford, Leicester).
As to why someone threw eggs at my flag, you tell me. I won't mention i live in an area where there are many foreign people

walk with Jesus! just look out for speedboats.
marhak
avatar
Posts: 4470

Posted:
25.Apr 2008 - 09:00

It shouldn't be banned on English soil (and shouldn't be flown on Cornish soil). So, if you're in England, fly it. Why shouldn't you? It's your flag. Resist all attempts to make you take it down and insist they take you to court - then tell the national Press. The thought police will back off like hell.

And someone has more money than sense. Eggs are bloody expensive these days.







edited by: marhak, Apr 25, 2008 - 08:03 AM
KarlT

Posts: 60

Posted:
25.Apr 2008 - 14:42

Just out of interest, Marhak, what would be your feelings about a Cornishman in England who flew a Cornish flag on St Piran's day? Given that I (as an Englishman in England) would have no objection, I'm a little mystified at the vehemence of your feelings towards people flying the English flag in Cornwall.



edited by: KarlT, Apr 25, 2008 - 02:44 PM
Eddie-C
avatar
Posts: 1189

Posted:
25.Apr 2008 - 17:49

KarlT whek,
Have you ever seen one of those 'alternate history' films, where Hitler's 3rd Reich successfully invaded Britain in the 1940s? You see Waffen SS and Wehrmacht goosestepping up Whitehall (or Sauchiehall Street), and Big Ben draped with black-white-and-red swastika banners, while the bands play the iconic Deutschland Über Alles and the Horst Wessel Lied. Doesn't that put a wee shiver of revulsion up your backbone?

Lots of the conquered Brits in such films (and even in the audience!) feel a strong antipathy towards the invaders, their language, flags, music and so on, don't they? And one might imagine such antipathy enduring, and even strengthening into mythical status, over ensuing generations in this fictional world.

Well, for a fictional Britain versus Nazi Germany try substituting an historical (Celtic) Britain vs. Anglo-Saxon Germany. Add in century after century of exploitation, suppression and conquest (be they perceived or real). That might give you some idea why St. George's flag gets a less-than-enthusiastic reception in the Celtic parts of the British Isles, even after so many centuries.

It might also give you an insight as to why Scotland, Wales, Man, Ireland and Cornwall have kept up the struggle over the centuries towards getting an increased measure of constitutional self determination, or even independence. And all of them bar Cornwall --I may need correcting here-- have succeeded to varying degrees.

Y-te agan deth-ny!

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

KS: selven an Furf Screfys Savonek? -- Ya, hep wow!

Kernewek Hengovek? -- Sur, nyns us nahen!
Bolitho
avatar
Posts: 29

Posted:
25.Apr 2008 - 18:31

What it didn't say in the thread or the paper is that the cross of St. George was taken down and replaced by a St. Pirans flag! The Bude town council then removed the Cornish flag within the hour...
Egloshal
avatar
Posts: 576

Posted:
25.Apr 2008 - 18:38

Are Bude town council anti-Cornish?

Radyo an Gernewegva
Eddie-C
avatar
Posts: 1189

Posted:
25.Apr 2008 - 18:43

Anti-Cornish? Perhaps merely anti-anti-Sasunnach!

Why not offer the local-government pissants a slot on your podcast to explain themselves?

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

KS: selven an Furf Screfys Savonek? -- Ya, hep wow!

Kernewek Hengovek? -- Sur, nyns us nahen!
Bolitho
avatar
Posts: 29

Posted:
25.Apr 2008 - 18:51

http://batcc.co.nr/

That's Bude Town Council for you...
goky
avatar
Posts: 1828

Posted:
25.Apr 2008 - 19:46

Eddie, do you live in Cornwall??

The blog The Great Goky Blog
Kéighlán
avatar
Posts: 440

Posted:
25.Apr 2008 - 20:52

Here you have it.
An official apology from an Englishman.
I am sorry my ancestors invaded you and treated you badly and your country is in the state it is today. I am sorry for the bitterness people give you and...im gonna be here all day. I apologize on behalf of England. There you go.

walk with Jesus! just look out for speedboats.
Bolitho
avatar
Posts: 29

Posted:
25.Apr 2008 - 21:40

Thanks. Can we have our Country back now?



edited by: Bolitho, Apr 25, 2008 - 09:41 PM
TGG
avatar
Posts: 1119

Posted:
25.Apr 2008 - 22:11

KarlT - Posted: 25.04.2008, 14:42Just out of interest, Marhak, what would be your feelings about a Cornishman in England who flew a Cornish flag on St Piran's day? Given that I (as an Englishman in England) would have no objection, I'm a little mystified at the vehemence of your feelings towards people flying the English flag in Cornwall.

KarlT, this comment here and others, from the same thread might also provide some answers to your questions. icon_smile

TGG For The (Real)Reason Why!


STOP THE CORNISH GENOCIDE!- The existence of divergent views occur because the lies and deception have a more profoundly negative, and contrived, consequence for the Cornish people than for anyone else within the UK.
Kéighlán
avatar
Posts: 440

Posted:
25.Apr 2008 - 22:15

Can you have your country back?
you already have it, just not officially. If its in your heart and mind, then its yours already.

walk with Jesus! just look out for speedboats.
Bolitho
avatar
Posts: 29

Posted:
25.Apr 2008 - 22:43

I wont be happy until the foreign oppressors are out of our Country.
Nothlenn
avatar
Posts: 221

Posted:
25.Apr 2008 - 23:50

Thinking seriously about what purpose there is to flying a patronal saint's flag, might it be that flags have erroneously been used to indicate a nationalistic passion rather than the nation's trust in the country's chosen saint to intercede with God for the good of the nation? For example, as everyone knows, Cornwall has a canonised saint for its patron, St Michael the Archangel, as well as an adopted one in St Piran. Oddly enough, St Michael is often portrayed rather like St George, with a spear in his hand which has pierced the dragon of evil. If we can call upon our saints to help us to do away with evil in our own lands, then that must surely be the be-all and end-all of celebrating the patronal saint's day.
http://tbn0.google.com/images?q=tbn:6K9jh-ZQj6jj0M:http://www.fotw.net/images/f/fr-50-ms.gif
Just for interest's sake, I have found the flag of le Mont St Michel, Breiz's equivalent of our St Michael's Mount (to which many came on pilgrimage from all over Britain). There is a certain similarity to the Cornish besants in those shells, and also to the black of the St Piran's flag. I believe the fleur de lys, being lilies, have a connection with Mary the Mother of Christ. There was once a lady chapel on St Michael's Mount which is now the 'Blue Room'. Perhaps we have over-secularised flags!



edited by: Nothlenn, Apr 25, 2008 - 11:52 PM
pdunbar

Posts: 245

Posted:
26.Apr 2008 - 14:10

NothlennThinking seriously about what purpose there is to flying a patronal saint's flag, might it be that flags have erroneously been used to indicate a nationalistic passion rather than the nation's trust in the country's chosen saint to intercede with God for the good of the nation?


Error doesn't come into it. Organised religion has ALWAYS had a symbiotic relationship with politics (and, indeed, religion is in itself a form of politics in that its promoters use it as a means of acquiring power over peoples lives), so symbols such as flags or indeed patron saints are used by different actors in different ways. However the aim of all such actors - seeking to unite the target population behind a particular agenda - is essentially political.

NothlennFor example, as everyone knows, Cornwall has a canonised saint for its patron, St Michael the Archangel, as well as an adopted one in St Piran.


As I understand it, the essential requirement of patron saints of nations is popular acclaim. Lacking such, one bunch of politicians or another (priests or the other sort) may try to promote a candidate in the hope of creating polular support (bit like a 'paper candidate' in an election).

If I am correct, Piran is yer only man. Not only that, but is there or has there ever been any evidence of popular acclaim throughout Cornwall (as opposed to, say, in Marazion) for St Michael?

Incidentally, whether or not Rome put its seal of approval on a saint by canonisation meant little or nothing to the Celtic Church.

NothlennOddly enough, St Michael is often portrayed rather like St George, with a spear in his hand which has pierced the dragon of evil.


The Church promoted the idea that evil and ignorance were synonymous with Paganism (and still does). A nice bonfire to warm your feet was the Church's means of coercion in the Middle Ages, used against anyone they took a dislike to (including Jeanne D'Arc - now that WAS an unholy (!) alliance of politics and religion!)

Slagging off other people's religions is not merely not PC today, but is a criminal breach of Human Rights legislation. Is there no litigious Pagan out there who is ready to take this up the next time the 'we're right and you're wrong, we're better than you are' organised religion lobby get uppity?

(Not that I'm a Pagan myself, but anyone having a pop at powermongers has my support)

NothlennIf we can call upon our saints to help us to do away with evil in our own lands, then that must surely be the be-all and end-all of celebrating the patronal saint's day.


Exactly. I don't know what evil the religious minority want done away with by St Piran when they march over Gear Sands, but the lay majority want an end to the non-recognition of the Cornish people and the domination of the same by a foreign regime.

- Pawl
Nothlenn
avatar
Posts: 221

Posted:
27.Apr 2008 - 14:20

First of all, let's examine the following taken off the Web:
QuoteWhat is a patron saint?
Patron saints are chosen as special protectors or guardians over areas of life. These areas can include occupations, illnesses, churches, countries, causes -- anything that is important to us. The earliest records show that people and churches were named after apostles and martyrs as early as the fourth century.
Recently, the popes have named patron saints but patrons can be chosen by other individuals or groups as well. Patron saints are often chosen today because an interest, talent, or event in their lives overlaps with the special area.
For example, Francis of Assisi loved nature and so he is patron of ecologists. Francis de Sales was a writer and so he is patron of journalists and writers. Clare of Assisi was named patron of television because one Christmas when she was too ill to leave her bed she saw and heard Christmas Mass -- even though it was taking place miles away.
Angels can also be named as patron saints. A patron saint can help us when we follow the example of that saint's life and when we ask for that saint's intercessory prayers to God.

Now you, Pawl, say:
QuoteIf I am correct, Piran is yer only man. Not only that, but is there or has there ever been any evidence of popular acclaim throughout Cornwall (as opposed to, say, in Marazion) for St Michael?

Certainly, I am no expert on historical fact but I have read enough to convince me that St Michael the Archangel has a special significance for Cornwall. See Page 102 of Catherine Rachel John's 'The Saints of Cornwall'
QuoteSt Michael's Mount was one of the three most popular Cornish places of pilgrimage
and
QuoteThe badge of St Michael, depicting him vanquishing the dragon of evil, was borne by both secular lords and ecclesiastics, notably by Robert, Count of Mortain, to whom was entrusted the government of Cornwall by his half brother William the Conqueror. 'I have borne the banner of St Michael in battle,' he declared. It is for such reasons that the archangel was, and is, regarded as Patron Saint of Cornwall, though not necessarily the only one (see Part One). He is called more widely a patron of the Celts.
http://saints.sqpn.com/saintm06.htm
http://hem.passagen.se/mikang/eng/html/pilgeng.htm
http://www.wilsonsalmanac.com/michaelmas.html
http://www.geocities.com/stmichaelsangels/
http://www.britannia.com/history/legend/cornish/cornss02.html and many other websites that refer to St Michael and Cornwall.

He is also patron of Helston while Piran is more properly regarded as the Patron of Tinners, I understand. Of course, St Petroc is Cornwall's third possible saint and more is known of his actual life.

I don't have an axe to grind over this except that I wanted to make an observation in my last posting. Personally, I thank God for the hope Christianity gives me rather than the horror that the past or present has offered us in the name of more than one religion. What is certain is that too much is talked about religion and not enough acted upon it, and all I know is that life and the future look bleak without it.



edited by: Nothlenn, May 04, 2008 - 08:35 PM
Kerrow

Posts: 336

Posted:
27.Apr 2008 - 14:57

Helston needs to look into the way St Michael has been replaced by St George in the Hal an Tow.

As you say, Nothlenn, St Michael is the Patron Saint of Helston.

The legend of St Michael includes the slaying of the dragon, and the connection is made here to the origins of the Furry Dance and the story of how a dragon flew over Helston and when he didn't attack, the people came out to celebrate.

May 8th is the day when the entire Latin Church celebrates the 'Apparition of St Michael' - the belief is that he appeared on May 8th 494 in Italy.

Marhak said recently that the red cross on a white background was originally that of St Michael - an Archangel and therefore a much more important Saint than St George.

It is not, unfortunately, the flag of St Michael that is flown from Helston church on Flora Day.
Nothlenn
avatar
Posts: 221

Posted:
27.Apr 2008 - 20:14

http://www.kindredspirit.co.uk/ARTICLES/IMAGES/5446_dance_of_dragon/st_michael_small.jpg
I'm so pleased you say what you've said here, Kernow. I couldn't agree more. That verse in the Hal an Tow about St George - and acted out on the day - must surely be the result of a confusion of dragons and their slayers! When a small boy, I was surprised to learn that a statue in our parish church was St Michael the Archangel - Cornwall's Protector - slaying a dragon, and not St George! But St Michael is said also to have appeared to fishermen out in Mount's Bay in 495 a.d. for which reason St Michael's Mount has long been a place of pilgrimage; there is a 'Pilgrim's Cross' on the island.



edited by: Nothlenn, Apr 27, 2008 - 08:18 PM
Kerrow

Posts: 336

Posted:
27.Apr 2008 - 20:25

I don't think it was a result of confusion, Nothlenn. I understand St George was brought in as a bit of Victorian propaganda.

Towns need to take more care of historical tradition.
Allister
online
avatar
Posts: 604

Posted:
28.Apr 2008 - 00:33

I have no problem with individuals flying their national flag in another nation's land (living in a university town in Wales I see many flags, English, Polish, South African, to name a few, and my trusty Cornish flag too) but public institutions and official buildings should not fly another nations flag. To do so is antagonistic and if, when asked, they do not remove such an offence, the people should remove it themselves.






I am awake at 4am to the terrifying undeniable truth that there is nothing I can do to stop the monster
Strattonian

Posts: 8

Posted:
29.Apr 2008 - 12:37

Some St George facts (open to corrections!):

St George was of middle-eastern origin
England's original parton saint was Edward the Confessor
England adopted the Cross of St George as its national flag as it was at the time, the civic flag of Genoa Italy, and therefore gave English vessels a flag of convenience when trading with the City State of Genoa
On St George's Day this year, English Heritage bemoaned the fact that more people celebrated Bon Fire Night than St George's Day - it is hardly surprising given that the English state so forcefully suppressed the veneration of Saints (killing thousands of Cornish in the process) and so vehemently encourage anti-catholic sectarianism (commemorating the burning of Guy Fawkes) - what the hell do they expect from a country with such deeply ingrained anti-Catholic heritage?
I for one, a proud Cornishman, see no problem commemorating St George or any other saint for that matter - today I am celebrating the Feast of Daniel!

Nothlenn
avatar
Posts: 221

Posted:
29.Apr 2008 - 23:26

Or how about
QuoteSt. Senan
Feastday: April 29
7th century

Welsh hermit. Owing to the confusion of records and traditions of this time and region, it is difficult to determine precise details of his life, but he is known to have labored in the northern districts of Wales.

Sennen obviously owes its name to this Celtic saint.
Mike
avatar
Posts: 2744

Posted:
30.Apr 2008 - 00:31

I'm reading St Senan was a christian Irish abbot of Inis cathaig (Scattery Island) but tradition insists this saint was female icon_smile
jezza
avatar
Posts: 275

Posted:
30.Apr 2008 - 12:17

Oh yes get the English out then Cornwall will be paved with gold right! icon_lol icon_lol icon_lol

If it wasn't for wealthy incomers Cornwall would be a cesspit. I'm English and proud! Ole ole ele England, ave it, oh yes! Football is an English sport that you all support.

There's more English in Cornwall than Cornish FACT. Stop your whinging.

The English are the best who founded an empire so put that in your pipe and smoke it. What language are you speaking now. What language are you reading now, boy.


















edited by: jezza, Apr 30, 2008 - 12:40 PM

Only true knowledge can set you free.
EngliscFyrd

Posts: 5

Posted:
30.Apr 2008 - 15:39

jezza> Part of the problem between building bridges between the English and Cornish movements is folk like you who post the sort of tripe you'd expect from a pissed up Millwall fan.

As for flying saints flags. I have no problem with Cornish people flying their flag in England what one does on ones own personal property is up to them. I have no problem with Welsh people or Scots or Irish doing the same.
I agree with the comment on official buildings should fly THEIR countries flag, however in the UK if proper recognition was given to all the countries I'd have no problem if another British countries national flag was flown on their saints day as an act of friendship.

As a side note with regards to English saints, England has three official saints, Edward the Confessor, Saint Edmund and St George.
P_Trembath
online
avatar
Posts: 1080

Posted:
30.Apr 2008 - 15:52

jezza Oh yes get the English out then Cornwall will be paved with gold right! icon_lol icon_lol icon_lol


If that's what you want!


jezzaIf it wasn't for wealthy incomers Cornwall would be a cesspit.


Please could we have some evidence for this "enlightening" fact?


jezzaI'm English and proud!


In the context of your post, all I can say is.......You can't help sickness.


jezzaOle ole ele England, ave it, oh yes! Football is an English sport that you all support.


No it's not, I never have, and I never will.
From the way you have worded that, it would seem that you are one of the hooligan's that gave your favorite "sport" such a bad name.


jezzaThere's more English in Cornwall than Cornish FACT. Stop your whinging.


Again, where is your evidence for this "enlightening" "fact"


jezzaThe English are the best who founded an empire so put that in your pipe and smoke it.


So did a lot of other bullies.


jezzaWhat language are you speaking now. What language are you reading now, boy.


The same language as the Americans, the Australians, the New Zealanders, the Canadians, etc.
Just goes to show how lazy the English are, making others speak their language because they are too bone idle to learn theirs.

Anyway, have a nice life in fantasy land. icon_lol icon_lol icon_lol






EngliscFyrd, well said.



Kernow Kensa!


Our day will come!


"Everyone has their own particular part to play. No part is too great or too small, no one is too old or too young to do something."
Kéighlán
avatar
Posts: 440

Posted:
30.Apr 2008 - 21:33

England has a few official saints, St Alban is one of ours who is actually English. And jezza, your obviously one of them people who knows nothing of history and stuff and goes around acting all proud to be English and give us a really bad name. Its not that we cant be bothered to leanr other peoples languages, in England we arent taught-like in other countrys-to speak other languages at very young ages, so we only pick up a small amount of their language when we finally learn in secondary school. And England has a terrible habit of invading other countries and making them speak English



edited by: Kéighlán, Apr 30, 2008 - 09:34 PM

walk with Jesus! just look out for speedboats.
marhak
avatar
Posts: 4470

Posted:
1.May 2008 - 08:42

We know - they did that to us.
Panini
avatar
Posts: 65

Posted:
1.May 2008 - 09:12

KéighlánEngland has a few official saints, St Alban is one of ours who is actually English. And jezza, your obviously one of them people who knows nothing of history and stuff and goes around acting all proud to be English and give us a really bad name. Its not that we cant be bothered to leanr other peoples languages, in England we arent taught-like in other countrys-to speak other languages at very young ages, so we only pick up a small amount of their language when we finally learn in secondary school. And England has a terrible habit of invading other countries and making them speak Englishedited by: Kéighlán, Apr 30, 2008 - 09:34 PM

Correct me if I'm wrong. But wasn't St. Alban a British Celt? I seem to remember St Alban's martyrdom taking place during the persecution of Christians under Emperor Septimus Severus in 209. And aren't the Anglo-Saxons thought to have arrived in Britain in the 5th century?
KarlT

Posts: 60

Posted:
1.May 2008 - 12:13

Yes, he was. But the "English" people of today are in large part descended from those same British Celts.
Nosdan
avatar
Posts: 1193

Posted:
1.May 2008 - 13:16

Really??? Have you proof of that?

Mar vedhow avel gelvinek
(as maazed as a curlew)
Panini
avatar
Posts: 65

Posted:
1.May 2008 - 14:23

KarlTYes, he was. But the "English" people of today are in large part descended from those same British Celts.

The "English" people of today may in fact be largely descended from British Celts. But do you think, then, that it is justifiable to backdate English history to include everything that happened before the arrival of the Anglo-Saxons?
KarlT

Posts: 60

Posted:
1.May 2008 - 15:46

Panini
KarlTYes, he was. But the "English" people of today are in large part descended from those same British Celts.

The "English" people of today may in fact be largely descended from British Celts. But do you think, then, that it is justifiable to backdate English history to include everything that happened before the arrival of the Anglo-Saxons?


Rather depends on how you define "English". If you mean "the history of the English people of today" then yes, the Celtic and Romano-British periods are part of that history. But if you're using the term more restrictively, to mean the elements brought in by the Anglo-Saxons, then of course not. So for most purposes no, but it does mean that English people, as heirs of a culture which derives from the Romano-British culture of St Alban as well as the Anglo-Saxon culture of the invaders, can claim to have a stake, as it were, in St Alban.
Kéighlán
avatar
Posts: 440

Posted:
1.May 2008 - 16:34

Righty, well, ask Marhak, he knows history and stuff lol. And there must be some English people today who have celtic ancestry, (i do, just look at my name) and the English are not only Anglo-saxon Germans. We have French, Danish, Norwegian and maybe even Swedish and Finnish ancestry. And i imagine not all celts moved towards Ireland, Wales, Scotland etc some must of stayed and integrated then ''mated'' with the newcomers.(English)

walk with Jesus! just look out for speedboats.
KarlT

Posts: 60

Posted:
1.May 2008 - 16:52

Erm - that's rather what I was saying.
moonshine
avatar
Posts: 1171

Posted:
1.May 2008 - 23:27

QuoteErm - that's rather what I was saying.


You have to keep it simply for the simple people.

So there's Duchy originals still in Cornwall and a right mish mash up-country.
marhak
avatar
Posts: 4470

Posted:
1.May 2008 - 23:47

I think there might have been an Anglo-Saxon presence (but not determined settlement) a bit earlier than the 420-450 AD main movement from Germany/Low Countries/Scandinavia. The Roman built "Saxon Shore" forts are about a century earlier and seem to have been trading posts for maritime trade across the North Sea, possibly run by AS entrepreneurs. Hard to prove that, though, but it seems feasible.

I have another theory (again unproven, so I merely offer it up)about the so far unanswered question of why south-western (Dumnonian) Britons colonised both Brittany and Galicia in the mid 5th century. There seems to have ben no real internal pressure that would force our people to move. Anglo-Saxon immigration had only just begun and that was 300 miles away, so wouldn't have affected Dumnonia in the slightest.

For this theory we go back to pre-Roman prehstory when we were an integral part of the Atlantic sea trading that had been operative since at least the early Neolithic (roughly when Celtic languages developed from Indo-European in those same areas, from Spain to Scotland, as a lingua franca of the trading nations, according to Cunliffe, Renfrew and others). It continued uninterrupted for 4500 years, until ended by one Gaius Julius Caesar in 56 BC. From then on, it was the Roman Empire that ran all import/export trade to and from Britain even before the Claudian invasion of 43 AD. That came to a close after the Roman withdrawal in 410 AD.

My theory is that Dumnonian entrepreneurs deliberately set up colonies in Galicia and Brittany as the two most strategic points on that old sea trading route, in order to restart and run it. We know from finds at Tintagel and other places that the old trading sea lanes were back in full swing by 450-500 AD and, if my theory is right, WE were in charge of them.



edited by: marhak, May 01, 2008 - 10:49 PM
KarlT

Posts: 60

Posted:
2.May 2008 - 09:40

Marhak - when you say "roughly when Celtic languages developed from Indo-European in those same areas" are you suggesting that the Celtic languages originated there, rather than further east around the Danube and then spreading West? I can see the idea of proto-Celtic as a Lingua franca for those areas, but I would see it as coming via migrations from the IE homeland somewhere between Eastern Europe and the Caspian; the people themselves would originally have spoken a non-Indo European Neolithic language, perhaps akin to Basque and/or Pictish*, and switched to Celtic as it increased in economic importance.

Perhaps it's a matter of definition. A dialect of Indo-European was introduced to the Atlantic coasts; at what point we call it "Celtic" is arbitrary. Most linguists, though, as I understand it, call it at least Proto-Celtic from an earlier stage when it first differentiated from proto Indo-European, probably in Eastern Europe.

I think the biggest problem I have with your Dumnonian entrepreneur theory is that I'm not sure that there was a strong enough communication, generation on generation, of history through the Roman period for the Dumnonians of the fifth century to actually know about the sea trading practices of half a millenium earlier. It's not exactly "Hey, cool, the Romans are gone, we can pick up where we left off", is it? That the post-Roman trading routes were the same might mean no more than that they were natural routes to use.

*There were apparently two Pictish languages - a Celtic one and a non Indo-European one. I'm talking about the latter.



edited by: KarlT, May 02, 2008 - 09:47 AM
KarlT

Posts: 60

Posted:
2.May 2008 - 09:46

Mike
Kéighlán1
yes it is illegal in some parts. i just didn't care it was St Georges day.
2
I had eggs thrown at my flag most probably because it's an English flag.


Where is it illegal to fly the CStG flag in England?


Nowhere. It's the Daily Mail version of reality, which bears little resemblance to the actual one.

QuoteWho would throw eggs at your flag in England?


The same sort of people who throw eggs at anything.
marhak
avatar
Posts: 4470

Posted:
2.May 2008 - 14:29

Karl, that's the old idea which has now been kicked well into touch. There is no mention of Danube area Celts until around 600 BC - which is pretty darn late. Apparently the Atlantic Celts have no genetic link with the later central European ones, who merely spoke a Celtic language. We imported their art and technology, and that's all. The general consensus now is that Celtic languages developed on the Atlantic coasts of Europe and Britain between 5000 and 4000 BC, and that there were no major movements of people in or out of Britain until the Claudian invasion gave the native Britons, with all those millenia of unbroken continuity, a hell of a shock.

The Romans were our first illegal immigrants, followed by the English, then the Danes, then the Normans.



edited by: marhak, May 02, 2008 - 01:30 PM
marhak
avatar
Posts: 4470

Posted:
2.May 2008 - 14:33

With the price of eggs as they are, they must have more money than sense.
KarlT

Posts: 60

Posted:
2.May 2008 - 15:47

marhakKarl, that's the old idea which has now been kicked well into touch. There is no mention of Danube area Celts until around 600 BC - which is pretty darn late. Apparently the Atlantic Celts have no genetic link with the later central European ones, who merely spoke a Celtic language. We imported their art and technology, and that's all. The general consensus now is that Celtic languages developed on the Atlantic coasts of Europe and Britain between 5000 and 4000 BC, and that there were no major movements of people in or out of Britain until the Claudian invasion gave the native Britons, with all those millenia of unbroken continuity, a hell of a shock.

The Romans were our first illegal immigrants, followed by the English, then the Danes, then the Normans.edited by: marhak, May 02, 2008 - 01:30 PM


Can you point to where I might find more on this "general consensus"? Under this new consensus, how did Indo-European get from its place of origin to the Atlantic coasts, there to develop into Celtic?

I wouldn't expect the Atlantic Celts to have a genetic link to the Continental ones under the old model; I would expect languages to move more than people, as different circumstances create different prestige languages.
deiniol

Posts: 15

Posted:
2.May 2008 - 22:21

marhakThe general consensus now is that Celtic languages developed on the Atlantic coasts of Europe and Britain between 5000 and 4000 BC
Um. The modern Celtic "peoples" might well have developed on the Atlantic coasts of Europe and Britain 5000-4000 BCE, and academic consensus might well agree with this (I have no idea if it does or not, I'm no archaeologist), but the Celtic languages certainly didn't.
Kéighlán
avatar
Posts: 440

Posted:
3.May 2008 - 18:18

The romans were less immigrants and more violent invaders. At least some saxons came here in peace and didn't totally ravage your culture to the way the romans did

walk with Jesus! just look out for speedboats.