| Topic: | THE PLACE OF DEATH!!!! |
|---|---|
|
Nosdan
Posts: 1169 Posted: |
Just came across this in Rev. Williams Dictionary, I wondered if anyone knew where this was? " In the four parishes of Redruth, Gwennap, Kenwyn, and St. Agnes, where, at a point, the four western Hundreds of Cornwall meet or unite, is a barren heathy spot denominated Kyvur ankou; where all self murderers belonging to those parishes are deposited by virtue of the coroner's warrant, a custom immemorial, whence the spot takes its name." Polwhelt's Cornish Glossary. And incase you don't know cornish, kyvur ankou litteraly means the Place of Death. I'm guessing it around Carnmarth somewhere? Marhak do you know? edited by: Nosdan, May 11, 2008 - 11:16 AM Mar vedhow avel gelvinek (as maazed as a curlew) |
|
TheElvenLord
online Posts: 957 Posted: |
That's interesting. On my map of the hundreds the 4 hundreds don't meet in one place. But its up along the coast from hayle (Heading north east) - according to my map. TEL Everything is impossible until it is not. |
|
Nosdan
Posts: 1169 Posted: |
I think its a bit ambiguous, I'm guessing its where the four parishes meet. And there is quite a bit of common land still around there, around Carnmarth. Just checked the old hundreds of Pydar, Powder, Kerrier and Penwyth did meet up at around the same place, I think. Penwyth was obviously a lot bigger then! Fingers crossed, marhak will know, when he turns up... edited by: Nosdan, May 11, 2008 - 12:24 PM Mar vedhow avel gelvinek (as maazed as a curlew) |
|
TheElvenLord
online Posts: 957 Posted: |
Yes. Let's hope so. Could this place be more of an area than a place. I mean, like an area of 1mile radius, which in that circle the Hundreds joined, but not neccesarily in one place. TEL Everything is impossible until it is not. |
|
Nosdan
Posts: 1169 Posted: |
I'm guessing from its description its an area of common land, a small area I would say... Big enough to hang a few people that's all. Mar vedhow avel gelvinek (as maazed as a curlew) |
|
TheElvenLord
online Posts: 957 Posted: |
"where all self murderers" Is this not for suiciders? Is it for Murderers? TEL Everything is impossible until it is not. |
|
morvran
Posts: 1294 Posted: |
It its where I think it is, then just up on the ridge are the remains of a stone circle. This point is on the main watershed between the outer (ocean) side and the inner (Mounts Bay) side of Penwith, and also on the main ridge bisecting W Penwith at right-angles to the first division, i.e. SW/NE. Definitely a significant spot. There is only one place in W Penwith where four of the traditional parishes meet. But I think the name contains _keverang_ "hundred" (territorial division). I don't think it has 'death' in it, any more than 'goat'. I dont know a word for 'place' that could fit this sound. That's the trouble when the language goes, people will come out with any old garbage and others knowing no better will believe them and pass the story on. Most Cornish 'folklore' has probably been invented over the last 150 years to amuse tourists, the real stuff would have gone down the tubes with the language, since apart from JCH and a couple of bits of songs, no one was interested in collecting or preserving this material. |
|
Nosdan
Posts: 1169 Posted: |
What Goat??? I think you right TEL i just read Murderers but I think its on about suicides... I think, It was some kind of evil sin to kill yourself so they probably put you as far away as possible.... ...and I suppose no other parish wanted the bodies! I wonder if the skeletons are still there somewhere... in someone's field perhaps? edited by: Nosdan, May 11, 2008 - 05:19 PM Mar vedhow avel gelvinek (as maazed as a curlew) |
|
morvran
Posts: 1294 Posted: |
From Nebbaz Gerriau Dro Tho Carnoak "... the Sieur Angwyn, the greatest and the eldest of the late proffessors of our Cornish Tongue, Who being desired to interpret Gevern Anko, prepossedded with the thoughts of Gever which signifieth Goates, and perplexed about Anko, concluded it was Goats all: Whereas it signifies the Bounds of the Hundred; Gevern he knew to be the Hundred, but forgot that the Word Ko was Cornish for remembering ..." "... an Empack Angwin an brauza ha an cotha Fratier mesk ul an clappiers Carnoack, a dewethaz rag guffiniez tho dismiggia, Gevern Anko, eue a reeg peverre war Gever, ha meskeeges dro tho Anko, eue levarraz droua Gever ul, eue a wya dro, Gevern buz nekovaz dro tho an geer "ko" dewethaz durt perhen Ko." (Some real Late Cornish there, clear as mud isn't it?) |
|
morvran
Posts: 1294 Posted: |
I may be thinking of a different place with the same original Cornish name. Or was Boson on about the spot near Carn Marth? Would that have been known to a Penwith Cornish speaker c1700?? The name fits as this is the only place in Cornwall where four hundreds (Kevrangow) meet at a point. I was thinking of four parishes meeting at a point. Seventy Percent of "competent & frequent" Cornish users prefer to write KK! (MAGA/CLP Survey) |
|
Mike
Posts: 2674 Posted: |
Is it confirmed that Carn Marth is the place where the 4 Hundreds meet? On another note, some Cornish photographers have recently displayed 360 Deg views from there, which are quite spectacular, on a clear day that is. |
|
morvran
Posts: 1294 Posted: |
The only maps I could find (quickly) on line showing the hundred boundaries were old ones with little detail, so I couldn't pin down the exact spot. Does anyone have them plotted on a modern detailed map? OS maps don't even seem to show parish boundaries these days. Seventy Percent of "competent & frequent" Cornish users prefer to write KK! (MAGA/CLP Survey) |
|
Mike
Posts: 2674 Posted: |
I used the Hundreds map in Padel's place name book and "transcribed" the 4 way join onto OS as approx Blackwater or Chiverton. |
|
porthia1947
Posts: 732 Posted: |
Well 'Polwhelt' might not have been that far off the track even though the translation has been misinterpreted..... It probably meant the name Gevern Anko was associated with a place of death in the folk memory. If the old hundreds of Pydar, Powder, Kerrier and Penwyth relate to more ancient 'tribal' areas it could fit. The tradition of burying executed people on tribal/royal boundaries may have been a local tradition or may even have been brought by the bands of Irish that came with the early 'christian' monks that arrived on Cornish shores in the 6th and 7th centuries. Who knows. edited by: porthia1947, May 12, 2008 - 07:45 AM |
|
Nosdan
Posts: 1169 Posted: |
In williams dictionary, he gives kyvur as (KK spelling) Kevar ~ Area of ploughable land. And Ankow ~ Death, wether this changed into a meaning of meeting of the hundreds I don't know... Perhaps all dead people were burried at the borders of hundreds? Its got to be somewhere between Scorrier, and Carnmarth... Where is marhak when you need him? Mar vedhow avel gelvinek (as maazed as a curlew) |
|
marhak
Posts: 3893 Posted: |
Here I am, complete with white charger, riding to the rescue (makes a change from the pub at Botallack). The place name Keverangow has been interpreted in some really weird ways, as some have shown in the bove posts. "Goats all" was one such! As Keith has said, it merely means "Hundreds" and was the site of a boundary stone on the Penwith/Kerrier boundary and where four parishes also met (Chacewater, St Day,St Agnes and Redruth). The spot is close to the motel at Scorrier. It was Assa Govranckowe in 1580, Kierancoe 1613, Keverancowe 1617, Gevar Ancho 1673, Kyver Ankou c1720 and Kyver Ancou 1790. The earliest one has the word Aswa, aswy, "gap, pass". The word turns up again on the Mount's Bay coast close to Prussia Cove where the rock marked on modern maps as "The Enys" was, in 1580, called Meenkeverangow ("Hundreds stone"). This is the seaward end of the Germoe-St Hilary parish boundary, which is also the Penwith-Kerrier Hundreds boundary. I can see where the suicide connection comes in. Traditionally, suicides were buried at crossroads in order to confuse the restless spirit which would not know which way to go should it rise from the grave. I suppose a spot where four parishes met would serve just as well. |
|
porthia1947
Posts: 732 Posted: |
Well marhak has responded and if the place is the meeting point of the hundreds and these hundreds were formerly 'tribal' areas then there is more here about the importance of these boundaries to 'Iron Age' and maybe later people. Although Gevern Anko may not be boggy land I assume if a 'tribal' boundary (whether the meeting place of 2,3 or 4 boundaries) it could be a place of burial for those dying by means 'outside the norm'. How traditional is the tradition is another question. edited by: porthia1947, May 12, 2008 - 09:27 AM |
|
Nosdan
Posts: 1169 Posted: |
The placename always has a K/c for ankou if it was kevrang(ow) would it not alternate... Also if it was a pass, why would you pass a hundred? surely its a smaller feature. With your placename evidence, and the testament of Polwhelt; I would think that Place of the dead is more fitting... also it kind of cool... Aswy kevar ankow ~ The pass of the Dead!!! I wonder if they've found any bodies there? Marhak want to bring your spade and will go for a dig? Mar vedhow avel gelvinek (as maazed as a curlew) |
|
KarlT
Posts: 60 Posted: |
Suicides were not considered worthy of burial in consecrated ground; it's actually theological nonsense but a lot of practices from that time had more to do with old traditions and superstition than theology. Suicides were also believed to be likely to rise as ghosts and were therefore often buried in obscure places or at crossroads where it was hoped they'd be too confused to nip home and haunt people. |
|
morvran
Posts: 1294 Posted: |
Sounds like a case of "not in my back yard", so you put it on the boundary which is the nearest you can get to nomansland, particularly if there was some uncertainty as to exactly where the boundary ran, if it went through a marsh or wasteland. OTOH the Celts did have a thing about boundaries, in both space and time, as being points that were neither quite this nor that, and so in some sense outside the normal framework. It's then easy to see how the idea arose that things supernatural could slip in through these cracks in reality. Kevrang/k is supposed to be cognate with Welsh cyfranc and Irish comhrac. The words seem to have originally meant a meeting or appointment, but later usually referred to an 'encounter', i.e. a battle or dual, commonly at a ford, which would usually be on the boundary between the disputed territories, or at least in a small piece of ritual nomansland. However the Cornish meaning of "Hundred" which I don't think is found elsewhere, suggests some sort of weopentake or local muster. Or did the sense of 'meeting (place)' originally refer to the boundaries between territories, and later get transfered to the units themselves, i.e. that which was contained withing the bounds? |
|
Nosdan
Posts: 1169 Posted: |
I'm still not sure, kyvur ankou has anything to do with Kevrang I think it just co-incidence that it looks similar. Of course i'm no expert. Mar vedhow avel gelvinek (as maazed as a curlew) |
|
morvran
Posts: 1294 Posted: |
Well ankow means 'death' or even 'Death' right enough, but kevar which is tentatively reconstructed from placenames, Breton and Welsh, means 'joint tillage' and so would refer to an area of arable land. It doesn't mean 'place'. Thinking further, ankow is the act, process or personification of death/dying. I don't think you'd use it to refer to 'the dead' or as the adjective 'dead' which would be marow plural possibly merow. So for example in PA we have : Rag own kavoez | y ankow "For fear of getting his death" i.e. being killed, but : Ev eth dhe'n korf | o marow "He went to the body which was dead". If I were asked to translate "place of the dead/death" I'd come up with something like tyller an verow or marowva. It wouldn't really occur to me to use ankow, but my instincts might well be wrong. What do others think? |
|
marhak
Posts: 3893 Posted: |
I always understood "ankow" to be the personification of death - the guy with the bloody great scythe, if you like. |
|
Nosdan
Posts: 1169 Posted: |
So do you think we should petition the council to erect a sign in scorrier, Aswy kevar ankow agas dynnergh? The pass of the area of land of Death welcomes you Mar vedhow avel gelvinek (as maazed as a curlew) |
|
Nosdan
Posts: 1169 Posted: |
On a more serious note, where does Kevrangow come from, entymologically speaking? It's extremely similar to 'kyvur ankou' and I wonder if there is any cross over of meanings? If suicide cases were buried at crossroads/border lands then perhaps the place name would turn up more often? and perhaps Kyver ankou was confused with kevrangow or visa versa??? Also 'Meenkeverangow' would not be hard to imagine a rock at sea associated with Death? Especially on the border with association of suicides.... .... What say you Marhak? Mar vedhow avel gelvinek (as maazed as a curlew) |
|
marhak
Posts: 3893 Posted: |
Kev(e)rangow cannot mean "place of death". As Morvran has said "kevar" translates as "joint tillage" and it simply would not fit (unless those who carried out the tillage worked themselves to death). We can always compromise, though. Accept that both place-names refer to their position on the old Hundreds boundary but erect a bloody great statue at Scorrier, looking right over the A30, of the old guy with the scythe. Might even have an beneficial effect on the speed freaks (as well as scaring the hell out of the tourists)! Oliver Padel has a workable suggestion, though. If "kev(e)rang" is analogous to Welsh <cyfranc>, "meeting, encounter, battle", Old Welsh <cibracma>, "meeting place, battlefield", Middle Breton <cuuranc>, "military assembly" and Old Irish <comrac>, battle, the Cornish <keverang, kevrang> could well have come to mean "district from which a military force could be drawn". One of the original six hundreds was Trigg, one of our oldest recorded place-names, which was, by the time of The Life of St Sampson, "pagus tricurius", meaning "land of three war hosts". It's interesting that it was later divided into three - Trigg, Lesnewth and Stratton. Maybe Padel is right with this suggestion; it certainly makes sense. edited by: marhak, May 13, 2008 - 08:10 PM |
|
Nosdan
Posts: 1169 Posted: |
Are you saying that, Assa Govranckowe ~ and the other names are (modern) Kevrangow rather than two seperate words, kyvur ankou? I'm a little confused? Those placenames to me look more like two seperate words than one. Also wouldn't you expect a few of the C/K alternating with G in ankow? What about the testament of polwhelt? Mar vedhow avel gelvinek (as maazed as a curlew) |
|
morvran
Posts: 1294 Posted: |
I wonder if an argument could be made for Carn Marth, or whatever hill is nearest to the four hundreds meeting point, as the W. Cornish equivalent of Uisneach, i.e. the local omphalos (spelling?) or geopolitical 'navel'. Any evidence/tradition of gatherings there in ancient times? |
|
marhak
Posts: 3893 Posted: |
There are Bronze Age barrows on Carn Marth but nothing that distinguishes it from any other hill top. How about the huge Neolithic complex on Carn Brea? |
|
Palores
Posts: 291 Posted: |
It is likely that the people who wrote the place-name as two words, spelling ankow with c or k rather than with g, believed that the name contained the word ankow. This is folk-etymology. They did not know the word keverangow. We know much more about Celtic linguistics than they did. |
|
Nosdan
Posts: 1169 Posted: |
Yeah but the placename evidence goes back to the 1500's when you would expect at few to know the language... And then theres the testament of Polwhelt, about the coroners warrant a custom immemorial. Sounds better than a Folk story. There must be some records, of suicides, back in the 16th century? What happened to them, where they were burried? How could I find out? Mar vedhow avel gelvinek (as maazed as a curlew) |
|
morvran
Posts: 1294 Posted: |
Judging by the cognates, kevrang probably ought to be kevrank. Seventy Percent of "competent & frequent" Cornish users prefer to write KK! (MAGA/CLP Survey) |
|
TheElvenLord
online Posts: 957 Posted: |
Could Marth (as in Carn Marth) be Death or something? Sounds close to Morts (Fr) somewhat. TEL Everything is impossible until it is not. |
|
Mike
Posts: 2674 Posted: |
Carn Marth = possibly Horses Tor/Crag |
|
marhak
Posts: 3893 Posted: |
All the early records show it as Carnmargh so, yes: margh, "horse" or possibly Margh (early Cornish: March) as a personal name. |
|
Abieuan
Posts: 272 Posted: |
I think the Breton word for death is "maro". The Scottish Gàidhlig word for dead is "marbh" (pronounced marv). |
|
morvran
Posts: 1294 Posted: |
No that's "dead". The bony fellow who talks LIKE THIS is "Ankou". Again "dead" and also the verb "to kill", Mharbh mi a' chaora "I killed the sheep". The word corresponding to C "ankow", B "ankou", W "angau" is eug (also with the same meaning but a different word, bàs). |
|
DenAnkoth
Posts: 62 Posted: |
I have found this thread very interesting. For what it's worth, I looked at a number of maps online, and it would appear that the meeting point of the four shires corresponds to a point on the modern A3047 where the road meets the footpath that backs onto Scorrier Close. However, only about 80 metres SW along the A3047, you come to the northern point of an equalateral triangle of land now occupied almost entirely by the Crossroads Hotel. On the 1908 map which I viewed on old-maps.co.uk, this triangle of land appears to be marked by stones, two along its NE boundary, and several seemingly close together at its SW corner. The SE corner is separated from the rest by the Great Western Railway. The Crossroads Hotel itself claims to sit on the site of the meeting place of the four ancient shires. Maybe this is Kevrangow. It looks like the old Radnor Road continued across the A3047, forming the southern boundary of the triangle, and that it was at this intersection (the original crossroads) where the shires met. The "Stones" marked at this point on the 1908 map could then have been the markers of the central meeting point.
|
|
Mike
Posts: 2674 Posted: |
Interesting stuff, ol'man, You've got me looking on the old maps. |
|
DenAnkoth
Posts: 62 Posted: |
It's addictive! I was doing some research on the kevrangow, and came across this discussion when I googled a few specific terms. I was already a registered user of Cornwall24, so I thought I may as well put in my tuppeny worth. I don't often contribute. You wouldn't happen to know anything about the origin of the original six kevrang names would you? I've just started a new thread asking for information about the name of Kerrier/Keryer.
|
|
Nosdan
Posts: 1169 Posted: |
I'm still not so sure that this place is purely named after the meeting of Keverangow... That quote from polwhele glossary about Coroners warrant and self murderers just seems to fit the place so well, and is in line with common practices of the time. Its a shame the hotel is built on the site, a dig would have proved it... Mar vedhow avel gelvinek (as maazed as a curlew) |
|
DenAnkoth
Posts: 62 Posted: |
I do find the kevrangow explanation convincing. On the g/k debate, MacBain's Etymological Dictionary of the Gaelic language has: The Celtic database of the Indo-European Etymological Dictionary (the IEED) at indo-european.nl has: Compare also, from IEED: and: It would seem that Cornish should be kevrank, but that maybe identification with the Welsh changed it to kevrang. Naturally, place names would be expected to preserve the older pronounciations. The original "Pass of the Cantons" would also indicate that this is the case. edited by: DenAnkoth, Jun 12, 2008 - 12:48 PM
|
|
DenAnkoth
Posts: 62 Posted: |
It should be added that the original sense was probably "reaching forward together" *kom- "together" *fro- "forward" *ank-o- "reaching". The later connotation of a fight or hostile encounter may have been a reference to the purpose of the "coming together", i.e. the kevrang was originally a meeting place for men fit to fight an enemy. The Aswa Kevrangow at Skorria doesn't have to imply hostilities between the various cantons of Kernow; but simply the place where an inhabitant of one of the four cantons could pass to any of the other three.
|