2nd person singular / plural :: Cornish Language, Culture and History

Main Menu

Cornwall Photos

full moon

full moon st ives...

barnoon chapel

st ives...

Boscastle

Boscastle on the north Cornwall coast...

seagull sunset

porthmeor beach...

User's Login

Vote!

[ Results | Polls ]

Votes: 100

Cornwall Information

Start :: Cornwall24 Discussion :: Cornish Language, Culture and History :: 2nd person singular / plural
Moderated by: Admins

	2nd person singular / plural
Panini	Posted: 08.06.2007, 10:42
registered: Jun. 2007 Posts: 65 Status: offline last visit: 20.05.08	In what circumstances were the 2nd person singular and the 2nd person plural used in historical Cornish? Is it true that God is always addressed with 2nd person singular in the historical texts? How do Cornish speakers use these two forms today?


FlammNew	Posted: 08.06.2007, 11:19
registered: Mar. 2006 Posts: 1814 Status: offline last visit: 27.03.08	I use 2s when referring to one person and 2p when referring to more than one person. 2p was used when talking to someone respectfully, but it's rare in modern usage. I can't say about references to God or other mythical beings, others here may know the answer. dukkha-samudaya-nirodha-magga


Fulub-le-Breton	Posted: 08.06.2007, 12:01
registered: Sep. 2004 Posts: 4147 Status: offline last visit: 07.08.08	In Breton there is a question of the informal 'you'(te) and the polite formal 'you'(c'hwi), a little like in french but the rules of use are different. The Cornish Democrat The Breton Connection


Bardh	Posted: 08.06.2007, 21:25
registered: May. 2007 Posts: 840 Status: offline last visit: 29.07.08	My clear impression is that, as in many languages, the familiar form is becoming normal in the singular. I can only think of two or three people who persist in addressing one person as several.


goky	Posted: 08.06.2007, 22:38
registered: May. 2007 Posts: 1317 Status: offline last visit: 28.07.08	Quotecan't say about references to God or other mythical beings, others here may know the answer So how do we address Ninja?? Blog Gokki,(Gokky's Blog)Skodhyewgh tesyans bys-efan ! Kernewek rag an Gour Gwir updated.


morvyl	Posted: 09.06.2007, 00:16
registered: Feb. 2006 Posts: 388 Status: offline last visit: 14.05.08	PaniniIn what circumstances were the 2nd person singular and the 2nd person plural used in historical Cornish? Is it true that God is always addressed with 2nd person singular in the historical texts? How do Cornish speakers use these two forms today? Today, Cornish speakers mostly use the 2sg. form for addressing one person and the 2pl. for addressing more than one person. Speakers of Revived Late Cornish (RLC) have a greater tendency to use 2pl. for one person. This reflects the tendency in the later period of the language for the 2pl. to spread. It appears to have been used between marriage partners. Maybe it spread analogously (if later) to the spread of English 'you' vs. 'thou'. God was always addressed with the 2sg. Subordinates were also occasionally addressed with 2sg. but then again we can see switches to the 2pl. within the same sentence in the story 'Jowan Chy an Hordh', so there appears to have been some confusion.


Laghyades	Posted: 09.06.2007, 02:51
registered: May. 2006 Posts: 212 Status: offline last visit: 29.07.08	One time, many moons ago, I was learning Russian. In Russian, the 2nd person singular is 'ti' and the plural is 'vi'. (Close enough without using Cyrillics). Anyway, 'ti' is the the 'familiar' and 'vi' is the formal. The older Russian folks are very, very picky about you using the correct one. I remember one time, a male student using the familiar pronoun 'ti' instead of the formal 'vi' to an elderly Russian gentleman. His response was "'Ti'?! Why do you say to me 'ti' ?! Did we at some time piss together in the same place?!" R-E-V-R-O-N-S, *Find out what it means to us.*


morvran	Posted: 09.06.2007, 02:59
registered: Mar. 2007 Posts: 1049 Status: offline last visit: 08.08.08	goky Quotecan't say about references to God or other mythical beings, others here may know the answer God himself being a trinity is very confused in the plays as to whether he's a ni or a my, so what hope is there for the rest of us? QuoteSo how do we address Ninja?? Nynz a^ an Ninja neb-pell -- a'm govis Ow mage vil gewsel Y'n kur foll gwann-wikkor fell Y fyls an Yeth ha fyllel


Bardh	Posted: 09.06.2007, 08:53
registered: May. 2007 Posts: 840 Status: offline last visit: 29.07.08	With the post code.

Users online:

porthia1947 - Griffin - pfishwick - TeamKernow - Verity - marhak - Shaz - moonshine - Cawsando

This list bases on the users active in the last 60 minutes

Cornwall News

Extra 'ingredient' in Cornish pie
A 21-year-old bites off more than he can chew when he discovers a whole snail is his Ginsters pasty.

Woman, 90, fulfils 'thong' wish
A 90-year-old has her fantasy fulfilled when she is served fish and chips by a waiter in a thong.

Man is murdered while walking dog
A murder inquiry is under way after the death of a man who was attacked while walking his dog.

Heating oil taken from home twice
A Cornish homeowner has hundreds of pounds worth of heating oil taken from his house in two separate thefts.

Rally called off over muddy field
One of the biggest steam rallies in the South West is called off after rain leaves the exhibition field too muddy.

Cinema on tour in Cornwall
Cinemagoers in Cornwall need no longer travel far to see great cinema.

Precious lives gets a wedding boost
Instead of the usual wedding gifts, a Lanner couple decided to ask for donations to charity.

Loads of fun in gardens
Gyllyngdune Gardens in Falmouth is piloting a host of activities and workshops over the summer.

independent Cornish news and comment

Main Menu

Who's Online

Cornwall Photos

User's Login

Vote!

The new Cornwall logo, is it...

2nd person singular / plural

Forum Latest

Cornwall Jobs

Cornwall News